Posted by: Andy Rice | March 18, 2008

America’s Cup DoG fight in July 2009

The 33rd America’s Cup will be a straight fight between Alinghi and BMW Oracle Racing in July 2009.

We think.

The Cup has been bogged down in such uncertainty these past months, but following Justice Herman Cahn’s ruling at the New York Supreme Court today that the Golden Gate Yacht Club is indeed the Challenger of Record – despite Alinghi’s protestations – it appears that the impasse has been broken with both teams now ‘resigned’ to a Deed of Gift match. Each blames the other for bringing the Cup to such a low point, after such a high last July.

This is a disaster for the challenger teams who have been waiting in the wings. July 2009 was the original timescale for the 33rd Cup, but now that none of the Shosholozas, Origins, Mascalzones or the many other potential challengers are invited, it will be hard for them to survive through to whenever the 34th Cup takes place.

Will Emirates Team New Zealand come back from this? It’s hard to imagine the New Zealand people could care much about the Cup any more.

For those that do still care, this is what lead counsel for the defending yacht club, Société Nautique de Genève (SNG), Lucien Masmejan, had to say:

“Following today’s court order, Larry Ellison has eliminated the competition and gained access to the America’s Cup Match, a feat BMW Oracle Racing has never been able to achieve on the water.

“While we are disappointed with the outcome of this court order and believe that the matter of GGYC’s certificate of challenge wasn’t properly addressed, we have decided not to appeal the decision and we look forward to getting the fight back on the water and meeting BMW Oracle Racing on the start line of a Deed of Gift Match in July 2009,” Masmejan said.

Should Alinghi win the Deed of Gift Match, the Defender says it is committed to getting the America’s Cup back on track for a world class multi-challenge event in 2011 in Valencia, Spain. “The challengers can be assured that the 34th America’s Cup will be run with the same vision and commitment for a premiere multi-challenge sailing event that they supported in Valencia in 2007,” Masmejan concluded.

BMW Oracle spokesman Tom Ehman commented: “We are very pleased with this decision. The Court has ruled that our challenge complied fully with the Cup’s Deed of Gift, and we are now keen to keep moving forward towards the next regatta.”

Responses

Awesome job BMW and Alinghi, not only have they managed to eliminate the competition but they have eliminated the interest in the Americas Cup.

Also….they have done irreparable damage to the sport in general. After years of getting rid of the upper class image to attract so much media and sponsorship into the sport, they have managed to throw all that good work away. Our sport (according to a taxi driver I used recently) is full of millionaires fighting each other in court. Perfect.

The americas cup has become a joke in the sport now and the people who I truly feel sorry for is the ones who work in the industry. What the upshot of all of this is that in their ignorance they have managed to destroy some peoples’ lives.

All that remains to be said is that I hope they really enjoy their penis jousting, the rest of us will get on with keeping this sport alive!

ISAF is having a really good time with multis. First multis are kicked out of the games and now the AC racing is very likely to be done in multis.

I could be wrong here but speaking of ISAF credibility…

Am I right in thinking that a senior ISAF measurer submitted evidence on whether a Cat can be described as a keelboat? And am I right in thinking that the judge effectively ruled against this submission in stating that a there is no reason a Cat could not be described as a keel boat?

If so I think ISAF urgently needs to look at its definitions.

Leave a response

Your response:

Categories